Cast
Justin McElroy
Self / Chris Evergreen
Travis McElroy
Self
Griffin McElroy
Self
Sydnee McElroy
Self / Tabitha Bigcity
Teylor Smirl
Self / Tabitha's Friend
Rachel McElroy
Self
Tommy Smirl
Self / Tabitha's Dad
Teresa McElroy
Self
Barbara Dunkelman
Self
Clint McElroy
Santa Clause
Carol McElroy
Professor Clause
Matt Chapman
Strong Bad (Voice) / Homestar Runner (Voice)
Rob Corddry
Self
Lin-Manuel Miranda
Self
Laser Malena-Webber
Self
Aubrey Turner
Self
Erika Ishii
Self
Amanda Coleman
Self
Mara Wilson
Self
Felicia Day
Self
Charlie McElroy
Self
Bebe McElroy
Self
Henry McElroy
Self
Ron Funches
Self
Jeremiah Watkins
Self
Ben Schwartz
Self
Mary Smirl
Chris' Mom
Melissa Fumero
Self
Krystina Arielle
Self
Dwight Slappe
Jesus Impersonator